Skip to main content
Homes for sale in Big Pine Key, Florida
Florida

Homes for Sale in Big Pine Key

“59 active listings in Big Pine Key, Florida · Average list price $1,110,273”

59 listings
Avg $1,110,273
174 days avg
Search All 59 Homes
Explore
Market Overview

Big Pine Key Real Estate at a Glance

Current market statistics for Big Pine Key, FL

59

Active Listings

$1.1M

Avg Price

$764

Price/Sqft

174

Avg Days

Price Range

From

$120,000

To

$4,850,000

Property Types

Single Family

43

Other

12

Multi-Family

3

Mobile Home

1

Nearby Cities

Explore homes for sale in cities near Big Pine Key, Florida

Marathon, FL
131 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Key Colony, FL
37 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Cudjoe Key, FL
16 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Ramrod Key, FL
13 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Big Coppitt, FL
13 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Stock Island, FL
13 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Summerland Key, FL
13 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Little Torch Key, FL
11 homes for sale
Within 25 mi
Listing selection

Homes to Explore

Active listings from the big pine key collection

31357 Avenue C, Big Pine Key, FL - $749K

$749K

31357 Avenue C

Big Pine Key, FL

31315 Avenue B - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL

$619K

31315 Avenue B

Big Pine Key, FL

30374 Oleander Boulevard - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL

$763K

30374 Oleander Boulevard

Big Pine Key, FL

31490 Avenue F - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL

$950K

31490 Avenue F

30525 Winifred Street - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL

$1.1M

30525 Winifred Street

More listings

More from Big Pine Key

More active listings from across the Big Pine Key market

31357 Avenue C, Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$749K

31357 Avenue C

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,451
31315 Avenue B, Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$619K

31315 Avenue B

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,352
30374 Oleander Boulevard, Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$763K

30374 Oleander Boulevard

Big Pine Key, FL

4 bd2 ba2,136
31490 Avenue F, Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$950K

31490 Avenue F

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd3 ba1,654
30525 Winifred Street, Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.1M

30525 Winifred Street

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd3 ba1,774
1632 Bogie Drive, Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.2M

1632 Bogie Drive

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd4 ba1,508
30468 Oleander Boulevard, Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$2.1M

30468 Oleander Boulevard

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd3 ba2,486
31450 Avenue G, Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.8M

31450 Avenue G

Big Pine Key, FL

4 bd3 ba2,323
Browse

Homes for Sale in Big Pine Key

Every active listing in Big Pine Key, browsable page by page.

30371 Warbler Lane - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$780K

30371 Warbler Lane

Big Pine Key, FL

2 bd2 ba1,364
31315 Avenue B - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$619K

31315 Avenue B

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,352
29667 Flying Cloud Avenue - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.1M

29667 Flying Cloud Avenue

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,320
251 Pelican Lane - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$740K

251 Pelican Lane

Big Pine Key, FL

2 bd2 ba1,200
2131 Coral Way - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$2.8M

2131 Coral Way

Big Pine Key, FL

4 bd4 ba2,100
173 W Cahill Court - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.1M

173 W Cahill Court

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,020
31095 Avenue A - Commercial for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Commercial

$799K

31095 Avenue A

Big Pine Key, FL

0 bd0 ba0
1669 Lantana Lane - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$895K

1669 Lantana Lane

Big Pine Key, FL

2 bd2 ba988
545 Ixora Drive - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.3M

545 Ixora Drive

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,368
3667 S Seas Street - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$924K

3667 S Seas Street

Big Pine Key, FL

2 bd2 ba1,124
29486 Ranger Avenue - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.2M

29486 Ranger Avenue

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,320
29207 Cypress Drive - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$775K

29207 Cypress Drive

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,152
31450 Avenue G - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.8M

31450 Avenue G

Big Pine Key, FL

4 bd3 ba2,323
31490 Avenue F - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$950K

31490 Avenue F

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd3 ba1,654
30374 Oleander Boulevard - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$763K

30374 Oleander Boulevard

Big Pine Key, FL

4 bd2 ba2,136
31441 Avenue F - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$975K

31441 Avenue F

Big Pine Key, FL

4 bd3 ba1,458
31364 Avenue J - Mobile Home for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Mobile Home

$765K

31364 Avenue J

Big Pine Key, FL

2 bd2 ba1,291
29038 Violet Drive - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.1M

29038 Violet Drive

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,064
31357 Avenue C - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$749K

31357 Avenue C

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,451
1632 Bogie Drive - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.2M

1632 Bogie Drive

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd4 ba1,508
29859 Overseas Highway - Land for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Land

$210K

29859 Overseas Highway

Big Pine Key, FL

0 bd0 ba0
1657 Watson Boulevard - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.1M

1657 Watson Boulevard

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,330
1518 Sunrise Drive - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.4M

1518 Sunrise Drive

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,540
30354 Palm Drive - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$500K

30354 Palm Drive

Big Pine Key, FL

2 bd2 ba1,030
31536 Avenue F - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.4M

31536 Avenue F

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,026
31032 Hollerich Drive - Multi-Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Multi-Family

$825K

31032 Hollerich Drive

Big Pine Key, FL

4 bd2 ba1,460
31135 Hollerich Drive - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.1M

31135 Hollerich Drive

Big Pine Key, FL

2 bd2 ba1,313
31179 Avenue H - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$510K

31179 Avenue H

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba960
21 County Road - Commercial for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Commercial

$179K

21 County Road

Big Pine Key, FL

0 bd0 ba3,240
29859 Overseas Highway lot: 19 - Land for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Land

$195K

29859 Overseas Highway lot: 19

Big Pine Key, FL

0 bd0 ba0
29517 Big Pine Street - Land for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Land

$400K

29517 Big Pine Street

Big Pine Key, FL

0 bd0 ba0
29034 Rose Drive - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$785K

29034 Rose Drive

Big Pine Key, FL

2 bd1 ba864
30860 Malaga Lane - Land for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Land

$150K

30860 Malaga Lane

Big Pine Key, FL

0 bd0 ba0
30525 Winifred Street - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.1M

30525 Winifred Street

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd3 ba1,774
3746 Park Avenue - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.1M

3746 Park Avenue

Big Pine Key, FL

2 bd2 ba1,312
29562 Saratoga Avenue - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.4M

29562 Saratoga Avenue

Big Pine Key, FL

4 bd2 ba2,310
30363 Flamingo Lane - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.7M

30363 Flamingo Lane

Big Pine Key, FL

4 bd3 ba2,136
3742 Seagrape Street - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$4.5M

3742 Seagrape Street

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd3 ba4,687
30375 Oleander Boulevard - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$540K

30375 Oleander Boulevard

Big Pine Key, FL

2 bd1 ba816
30582 5th Avenue - Commercial for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Commercial

$895K

30582 5th Avenue

Big Pine Key, FL

0 bd0 ba0
1540 Lantana Lane - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$899K

1540 Lantana Lane

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,418
1540 Lantana Lane - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$899K

1540 Lantana Lane

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,418
29635 Saratoga Avenue - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$1.4M

29635 Saratoga Avenue

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,396
1719 Narcissus Avenue - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$729K

1719 Narcissus Avenue

Big Pine Key, FL

2 bd2 ba912
30368 Killdeer Lane - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$965K

30368 Killdeer Lane

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,200
31478 Avenue E - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$460K

31478 Avenue E

Big Pine Key, FL

1 bd1 ba557
31033 Hibiscus Drive - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$699K

31033 Hibiscus Drive

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd2 ba1,224
Vacant Land lot: 6 - Land for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Land

$120K

Vacant Land lot: 6

Big Pine Key, FL

0 bd0 ba0
30330 - 30348 Overseas Highway - Commercial for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Commercial

$3.1M

30330 - 30348 Overseas Highway

Big Pine Key, FL

0 bd9 ba5,250
30468 Oleander Boulevard - Single Family for sale in Big Pine Key, FL
Single Family

$2.1M

30468 Oleander Boulevard

Big Pine Key, FL

3 bd3 ba2,486

Showing 1–50 of 59 · Page 1 of 2

Beyond the listings

Continue exploring Big Pine Key

Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Big Pine Key market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.

Refine Big Pine Key searchAll Florida homes
Local market guide

Big Pine Key Housing Market

Browse 59 active listings in Big Pine Key, Florida. The average list price for this active inventory is $1,110,273. Compare the price and property details reported in each listing.

Average list price $1,110,273 · Range $120,000–$4,850,000 · 59 active listings

Buyer questions

Frequently Asked Questions

How many active listings are available in Big Pine Key, Florida?

The current inventory contains 59 active listings in Big Pine Key, FL.

What is the average list price in Big Pine Key, Florida?

The average list price among current active listings in Big Pine Key, FL is $1,110,273. Current list prices range from $120,000 to $4,850,000.

What is the average days on market for active listings in Big Pine Key?

Current active listings in Big Pine Key, FL report an average of 174 days on market.

What is the average list price per square foot in Big Pine Key?

The average list price per square foot among current active listings in Big Pine Key, FL is $764.

Shape your search

Browse Big Pine Key by home feature

Homes with Solar FeaturesHomes with EV ChargersHomes with PoolsWaterfront HomesHomes with ViewsHomes with Recorded Price ReductionsListings Added to PropertySimple in the Past 7 DaysHomes Built Since 2024

Nationwide collections

Explore by listing details

Waterfront ListingsListings Marked WaterfrontListings in Mountain StatesSix-State CollectionMulti-Family & Commercial ListingsListings by Property TypeListings with 3+ BedroomsThree or More BedroomsListings Priced at $1.5M+Listings by Asking PriceListings Built Since 2015Listings by Year Built

Ready to make the list yours?

Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Big Pine Key.

Search Big Pine Key homes