Michigan
Homes for Sale in New Buffalo
“Discover your next home in New Buffalo”
63 listings
Avg $692,902
65 days avg
Explore
Market Overview
New Buffalo Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for New Buffalo, MI
63
Active Listings
$693K
Avg Price
$449K
Median Price
2,324
Avg Sqft
65
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$29,999
To
$3,999,999
Handpicked
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest new buffalo homes homes
Featured
More New Buffalo Homes
Discover more properties that match this lifestyle
Single Family
$1.7M
51212 Deer Park Drive
New Buffalo, MI
3 bd4 ba3,844
Single Family
$650K
12589 Ed Berth Drive
New Buffalo, MI
3 bd2 ba2,825
Single Family
$449K
18840 Spring Street
New Buffalo, MI
6 bd4 ba2,991
Single Family
$325K
12366 Lubke Road
New Buffalo, MI
3 bd2 ba1,600
Single Family
$2.2M
16140 Stones Throw Lane
New Buffalo, MI
5 bd5 ba3,330
Single Family
$975K
1407 Shore Drive
New Buffalo, MI
4 bd3 ba2,780
Single Family
$620K
1 S Griffith Street
New Buffalo, MI
3 bd2 ba2,708
Single Family
$352K
923 Bell Avenue
New Buffalo, MI
4 bd2 ba1,134
Browse
Homes for Sale in New Buffalo
Every active listing in New Buffalo, browsable page by page.
Single Family
$429K
226 S Barker Street
New Buffalo, MI
2 bd1 ba900
Single Family
$650K
12589 Ed Berth Drive
New Buffalo, MI
3 bd2 ba2,825
Single Family
$1.8M
13309 Wilson Road
New Buffalo, MI
4 bd3 ba2,191
Single Family
$660K
1359 Bell Avenue
New Buffalo, MI
3 bd2 ba1,350
Single Family
$989K
4035 Choctaw Trail
New Buffalo, MI
5 bd3 ba3,269
Single Family
$2.2M
16140 Stones Throw Lane
New Buffalo, MI
5 bd5 ba3,330
Single Family
$499K
823 W Merchant Street
New Buffalo, MI
3 bd1 ba1,268
Single Family
$699K
4175 Creek Drive
New Buffalo, MI
5 bd3 ba1,506
Land
$78K
85 Diamond Point Lane
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$79K
109 Diamond Point Lane
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$83K
107 Diamond Point Lane
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$77K
95 Diamond Point Lane
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$83K
96 Diamond Point Lane
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$83K
98 Diamond Point Lane
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$81K
101 Diamond Point Lane
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$78K
90 Diamond Point Lane
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$81K
105 Diamond Point Lane
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$80K
110 Diamond Point Lane
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$77K
97 Diamond Point Lane
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$300K
816 & 820 E Indiana Circle
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$150K
820 E Indiana Street
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$150K
816 E Indiana Street
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$449K
18840 Spring Street
New Buffalo, MI
6 bd4 ba2,991
Land
$1.9M
4281 Lake Shore Drive
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$3.9M
331 Marquette Drive
New Buffalo, MI
6 bd5 ba5,538
Single Family
$1.7M
51212 Deer Park Drive
New Buffalo, MI
3 bd4 ba3,844
Land
$225K
19818 M-239
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$95K
315 S Clinton Street
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$646K
4160 Comanche Trail
New Buffalo, MI
2 bd2 ba1,100
Land
$30K
366 Peninsula
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$200K
01 Hoder A, B, C Road
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Residential Multi Family
$590K
121 E Michigan Street
New Buffalo, MI
7 bd0 ba
Single Family
$352K
923 Bell Avenue
New Buffalo, MI
4 bd2 ba1,134
Condo
$330K
14 Lighthouse Point
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd1 ba400
Land
$500K
18906 S Lakeside Road
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$540K
49209 Howard Avenue
New Buffalo, MI
4 bd2 ba1,892
Land
$130K
17708 Thunder Road lot: 10
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$250K
14386 Wolf Lane
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$183K
17859 Behner Road
New Buffalo, MI
1 bd1 ba680
Single Family
$400K
209 S Marshall Street
New Buffalo, MI
3 bd2 ba1,082
Condo
$1.1M
409 Lake Drive
New Buffalo, MI
2 bd2 ba1,164
Land
$43K
84 Harbor Landing
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Commercial
$1.3M
19747 U.S. 12
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Condo
$630K
1501 W Water Street
New Buffalo, MI
3 bd3 ba2,284
Commercial
$400K
427 S Whittaker Street
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd2 ba1,500
Single Family
$370K
721 W Michigan Street
New Buffalo, MI
2 bd1 ba900
Single Family
$4.0M
3987 Lake Shore Drive
New Buffalo, MI
7 bd5 ba4,913
Single Family
$1M
131 S Mayhew Street
New Buffalo, MI
4 bd4 ba3,000
Land
$60K
19499 Kluver Road
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$579K
01 Hoder Road
New Buffalo, MI
0 bd0 ba
Showing 1–50 of 64 · Page 1 of 2
About New Buffalo Real Estate
New Buffalo, Michigan offers a diverse real estate market with 63 homes currently for sale. Whether you're looking for a starter home, family property, or luxury estate, New Buffalo has options for every budget and lifestyle.
Average listing price: $692,902 · 63 homes available