Michigan
Homes for Sale in Suttons Bay
“Discover your next home in Suttons Bay”
56 listings
Avg $1,018,823
104 days avg
Explore
Market Overview
Suttons Bay Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Suttons Bay, MI
56
Active Listings
$1.0M
Avg Price
$750K
Median Price
3,259
Avg Sqft
104
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$37,500
To
$5,400,000
Handpicked
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest suttons bay homes homes
Featured
More Suttons Bay Homes
Discover more properties that match this lifestyle
Single Family
$1.6M
1476 Brencris Lane
Suttons Bay, MI
6 bd3 ba3,830
Single Family
$1.1M
470 S Donnybrook Road
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba2,800
Single Family
$925K
2567 N Evergreen Valley Drive
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba3,699
Single Family
$735K
1474 S Montmorency Lane
Suttons Bay, MI
5 bd4 ba4,166
Single Family
$1.5M
10041 E John Michael Drive
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba3,051
Condo
$1.1M
764 N Waypoint Circle
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba2,493
Single Family
$995K
6261 S Westwood Pkwy
Suttons Bay, MI
5 bd4 ba3,676
Single Family
$589K
12166 E Old Orchard Trail
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba2,648
Browse
Homes for Sale in Suttons Bay
Every active listing in Suttons Bay, browsable page by page.
Single Family
$1.6M
1476 Brencris Lane
Suttons Bay, MI
6 bd3 ba3,830
Single Family
$890K
10953 E Pobuda Road
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba2,134
Single Family
$589K
12166 E Old Orchard Trail
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba2,648
Single Family
$320K
10510 E Shady Lane
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd2 ba1,154
Single Family
$2.6M
737 S Stony Point Road
Suttons Bay, MI
4 bd2 ba2,287
Single Family
$949K
800 N St Joseph Street
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd1 ba1,200
Single Family
$995K
6261 S Westwood Pkwy
Suttons Bay, MI
5 bd4 ba3,676
Single Family
$1.5M
10041 E John Michael Drive
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba3,051
Single Family
$1.5M
488 S Stony Point Road
Suttons Bay, MI
2 bd2 ba1,662
Single Family
$499K
5910 S Cummings
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd2 ba1,176
Condo
$475K
11255 E Fort Road
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd2 ba1,244
Single Family
$665K
151 S Crestwood Drive
Suttons Bay, MI
4 bd2 ba1,914
Single Family
$1.9M
3784 S Lee Point Road
Suttons Bay, MI
2 bd2 ba1,337
Single Family
$1.2M
2768 S Center Highway
Suttons Bay, MI
2 bd2 ba1,836
Condo
$1.3M
704 N Dockside Circle
Suttons Bay, MI
4 bd3 ba2,275
Single Family
$1.9M
1059 S Nanagosa
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba2,984
Land
$350K
0 E Smiseth Road
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$149K
112 W Madison Avenue
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Condo
$995K
750 N Waypoint Circle
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba2,493
Single Family
$1.1M
470 S Donnybrook Road
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba2,800
Condo
$750K
760 Waypoint Circle
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba2,493
Land
$950K
0 M-22
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Condo
$750K
758 Waypoint Circle
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba2,493
Land
$90K
00 E Sugar Maple Court
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$925K
2567 N Evergreen Valley Drive
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba3,699
Land
$38K
1955 N Blue Water Court
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$42K
1949 N Blue Water Court
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Condo
$1.1M
764 N Waypoint Circle
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba2,493
Land
$79K
1912 N Blue Water Court
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Condo
$585K
236 N Front Street
Suttons Bay, MI
2 bd2 ba1,032
Land
$89K
2155 N Belanger Creek Drive
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$199K
2171 N Belanger Creek Drive
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$140K
2164 N Belanger Creek Drive
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$210K
1881 N Blue Water Court
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$735K
1474 S Montmorency Lane
Suttons Bay, MI
5 bd4 ba4,166
Condo
$1.2M
766 N Waypoint Circle
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd2 ba2,493
Condo
$799K
762 N Waypoint Circle
Suttons Bay, MI
3 bd3 ba2,493
Commercial
$3.0M
5046 S West Bay Shore
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd11 ba18,000
Commercial
$1.4M
5046 S West Bay Shore
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba8,702
Commercial
$199K
5046 S West Bay Shore Drive
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$199K
5046 S West Bay Shore Drive
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Land
$199K
5046 S West Bay Shore Drive
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Commercial
$199K
5046 S West Bay Shore Drive
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$1.1M
9224 E Duck Lake Road
Suttons Bay, MI
4 bd1 ba1,783
Commercial
$5.4M
9224 E Duck Lake Road
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba1,783
Land
$60K
1909 N Blue Water Court
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Commercial
$699K
5046 S West Bay Shore
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba2,751
Commercial
$825K
1375 West Bay Shore Drive
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba3,187
Commercial
$900K
5046 S West Bay Shore
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba4,032
Land
$5.4M
9224 E Duck Lake Road
Suttons Bay, MI
0 bd0 ba
Showing 1–50 of 57 · Page 1 of 2
About Suttons Bay Real Estate
Suttons Bay, Michigan offers a diverse real estate market with 56 homes currently for sale. Whether you're looking for a starter home, family property, or luxury estate, Suttons Bay has options for every budget and lifestyle.
Average listing price: $1,018,823 · 56 homes available