New York
Homes for Sale in Bay Shore
“Discover your next home in Bay Shore”
41 listings
Avg $823,843
86 days avg
Explore
Market Overview
Bay Shore Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Bay Shore, NY
41
Active Listings
$824K
Avg Price
$679K
Median Price
1,735
Avg Sqft
86
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$34,900
To
$3,499,000
Handpicked
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest bay shore homes homes
Featured
More Bay Shore Homes
Discover more properties that match this lifestyle
Single Family
$869K
82 Sunset Road
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd3 ba2,500
Single Family
$725K
175 Candlewood Road
Bay Shore, NY
7 bd2 ba2,110
Single Family
$640K
1327 Brooklyn Boulevard
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd3 ba2,184
Single Family
$570K
1563 Baldwin Boulevard
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd3 ba1,559
Single Family
$825K
28 Hemlock Lane
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd3 ba2,371
Single Family
$749K
2 Burnett Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd3 ba1,746
Single Family
$650K
24 5th Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd2 ba1,858
Single Family
$590K
1013 Merriam Road
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd2 ba1,493
Browse
Homes for Sale in Bay Shore
Every active listing in Bay Shore, browsable page by page.
Single Family
$825K
28 Hemlock Lane
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd3 ba2,371
Single Family
$600K
19 Westside Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd3 ba1,282
Single Family
$1.0M
957 Gardiner Drive
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd3 ba2,067
Single Family
$640K
1327 Brooklyn Boulevard
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd3 ba2,184
Single Family
$525K
70 E Lakeland Street
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd1 ba800
Single Family
$600K
332 Delaware Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd1 ba1,263
Single Family
$700K
1372 Pine Drive
Bay Shore, NY
5 bd2 ba1,734
Single Family
$649K
1084 Hyman Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd2 ba1,220
Single Family
$719K
1333 Boston Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd3 ba1,596
Single Family
$575K
110 Penataquit Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd2 ba1,193
Single Family
$869K
82 Sunset Road
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd3 ba2,500
Single Family
$680K
1426 Ackerson Boulevard
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd2 ba
Single Family
$900K
939 Manor Lane
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd3 ba2,329
Single Family
$725K
175 Candlewood Road
Bay Shore, NY
7 bd2 ba2,110
Single Family
$640K
1056 Ocean Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd2 ba1,289
Single Family
$250K
5 Pinebrook Place
Bay Shore, NY
1 bd1 ba
Single Family
$1.5M
9 Dove Lane
Bay Shore, NY
5 bd5 ba3,905
Commercial
$750K
11 S Park Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$659K
8 Oswego Drive
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd1 ba1,742
Single Family
$649K
33 W Lakeland Street
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd2 ba1,639
Single Family
$590K
1013 Merriam Road
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd2 ba1,493
Single Family
$800K
2 Hemlock Court
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd2 ba2,300
Single Family
$729K
1374 Saxon Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd2 ba1,658
Single Family
$649K
90 Sunset Road
Bay Shore, NY
2 bd2 ba1,582
Single Family
$720K
7 E Lakeland Street
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd2 ba1,248
Condo
$799K
6 Villa Promenade
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd3 ba1,992
Single Family
$540K
41 Princeton Street
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd2 ba1,410
Single Family
$679K
802 Nebraska Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd2 ba1,440
Single Family
$770K
31 Circle Lane
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd3 ba1,827
Single Family
$150K
1233 sunrise highway
Bay Shore, NY
0 bd0 ba
Commercial
$35K
1575 5th Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$900K
47 Drayton Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
5 bd3 ba2,066
Single Family
$595K
1016 Howells Road
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd1 ba800
Single Family
$749K
2 Burnett Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd3 ba1,746
Single Family
$1.4M
108 Awixa Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
6 bd5 ba2,854
Single Family
$615K
1181 Ocean Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd2 ba1,772
Single Family
$668K
1097 Carll Drive
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd1 ba1,132
Single Family
$245K
19 Newbrook
Bay Shore, NY
1 bd1 ba870
Single Family
$1.4M
70 Park Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$570K
1563 Baldwin Boulevard
Bay Shore, NY
3 bd3 ba1,559
Single Family
$650K
24 5th Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
4 bd2 ba1,858
Commercial
$3.0M
24 Cottage Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
0 bd0 ba
Commercial
$3.5M
375 Suite 8-12-28 and 381 E Main Street
Bay Shore, NY
0 bd0 ba
Showing 1–43 of 43 · Page 1 of 1
About Bay Shore Real Estate
Bay Shore, New York offers a diverse real estate market with 41 homes currently for sale. Whether you're looking for a starter home, family property, or luxury estate, Bay Shore has options for every budget and lifestyle.
Average listing price: $823,843 · 41 homes available