New York
Homes for Sale in Jay
“Discover your next home in Jay”
28 listings
Avg $362,603
171 days avg
Explore
Market Overview
Jay Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Jay, NY
28
Active Listings
$363K
Avg Price
$357K
Median Price
1,676
Avg Sqft
171
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$31,500
To
$995,000
Handpicked
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest jay homes homes
Featured
More Jay Homes
Discover more properties that match this lifestyle
Single Family
$689K
93 Beech Street
Jay, NY
6 bd3 ba3,840
Single Family
$415K
12984 NYS Route 9N
Jay, NY
5 bd3 ba2,622
Single Family
$365K
259 River Road
Jay, NY
4 bd2 ba2,179
Single Family
$255K
22 Fawn Lane
Jay, NY
3 bd1 ba1,024
Single Family
$800K
32 Seneca Trail
Jay, NY
3 bd4 ba2,986
Single Family
$380K
44 Butternut Lane
Jay, NY
4 bd2 ba1,268
Single Family
$369K
18 Elm Street
Jay, NY
3 bd2 ba1,300
Single Family
$169K
689 Glen Road
Jay, NY
2 bd1 ba936
Browse
Homes for Sale in Jay
Every active listing in Jay, browsable page by page.
Single Family
$995K
6487 NYS Rt 86
Jay, NY
7 bd5 ba3,750
Land
$32K
38 Algonquin Lane
Jay, NY
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$369K
18 Elm Street
Jay, NY
3 bd2 ba1,300
Single Family
$379K
621 Ausable Drive
Jay, NY
4 bd2 ba1,206
Single Family
$329K
84 Sawmill Drive
Jay, NY
2 bd1 ba928
Single Family
$290K
184 Sequoia Mountain Lane
Jay, NY
1 bd2 ba1,122
Mobile Home
$90K
7 Covered Bridge Ln
Jay, NY
3 bd2 ba1,508
Land
$179K
369 Upper Jay-Trumbulls Corners Road
Jay, NY
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$349K
109 Tannenbaum Lane
Jay, NY
2 bd2 ba864
Single Family
$415K
12984 NYS Route 9N
Jay, NY
5 bd3 ba2,622
Single Family
$255K
22 Fawn Lane
Jay, NY
3 bd1 ba1,024
Land
$105K
109 Ridge Top Road
Jay, NY
0 bd0 ba
Commercial
$599K
97 Danielle Road
Jay, NY
0 bd0 ba2,100
Single Family
$599K
97 Danielle Road
Jay, NY
2 bd2 ba2,100
Single Family
$365K
259 River Road
Jay, NY
4 bd2 ba2,179
Single Family
$380K
44 Butternut Lane
Jay, NY
4 bd2 ba1,268
Single Family
$169K
689 Glen Road
Jay, NY
2 bd1 ba936
Single Family
$689K
93 Beech Street
Jay, NY
6 bd3 ba3,840
Single Family
$410K
14 Antler Drive
Jay, NY
2 bd2 ba1,232
Single Family
$399K
26 Summit Lane
Jay, NY
2 bd1 ba992
Single Family
$239K
106 Alder Street
Jay, NY
2 bd1 ba756
Single Family
$800K
32 Seneca Trail
Jay, NY
3 bd4 ba2,986
Single Family
$625K
205 River Road
Jay, NY
4 bd3 ba2,228
Single Family
$450K
60 Gooseberry Lane
Jay, NY
4 bd2 ba2,091
Land
$175K
571 Stickney Bridge Road
Jay, NY
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$198K
67 Alder St.
Jay, NY
3 bd1 ba817
Land
$35K
186 lot Spruce Lane
Jay, NY
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$235K
64 Beech Street
Jay, NY
2 bd1 ba694
Showing 1–28 of 28 · Page 1 of 1
About Jay Real Estate
Jay, New York offers a diverse real estate market with 28 homes currently for sale. Whether you're looking for a starter home, family property, or luxury estate, Jay has options for every budget and lifestyle.
Average listing price: $362,603 · 28 homes available