New York
Homes for Sale in Middletown
“Discover 59 homes in Middletown, New York”
59 listings
Avg $697,113
79 days avg
Explore
Market Overview
Middletown Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Middletown, NY
59
Active Listings
$697K
Avg Price
$575K
Median Price
$326
Price/Sqft
2,139
Avg Sqft
79
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$39,000
To
$3,000,000
Nearby Cities
Explore homes for sale in cities near Middletown, New York
Milford, Pennsylvania
110 homes for sale
28 mi away
Hawley, Pennsylvania
78 homes for sale
37 mi away
Bushkill, Pennsylvania
109 homes for sale
39 mi away
Greentown, Pennsylvania
59 homes for sale
44 mi away
Yonkers, NY
142 homes for sale
46 mi away
East Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania
154 homes for sale
47 mi away
Lake Ariel, Pennsylvania
111 homes for sale
48 mi away
Ridgefield, Connecticut
21 homes for sale
49 mi away
Handpicked
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest middletown homes homes
Featured
More Middletown Homes
Discover more properties that match this lifestyle
Single Family
$675K
225 Brown Road
Middletown, NY
4 bd3 ba4,080
Single Family
$575K
180 Mt Orange Road
Middletown, NY
5 bd2 ba2,432
Single Family
$450K
3 Arden Court
Middletown, NY
3 bd3 ba2,427
Condo
$300K
2 S Aspen Road
Middletown, NY
3 bd2 ba1,884
Single Family
$839K
225 Van Duzer Road
Middletown, NY
6 bd4 ba3,900
Single Family
$580K
30 Daly Road
Middletown, NY
3 bd3 ba2,205
Single Family
$449K
60 Peach Place
Middletown, NY
3 bd4 ba2,041
Condo
$318K
47 Brick Pond Road
Middletown, NY
2 bd2 ba1,460
Browse
Homes for Sale in Middletown
Every active listing in Middletown, browsable page by page.
Single Family
$225K
45 John Street
Middletown, NY
2 bd1 ba921
Single Family
$289K
4 Hulse Street
Middletown, NY
2 bd1 ba806
Condo
$399K
19 Putters Way
Middletown, NY
2 bd3 ba1,337
Condo
$165K
226 Concord Lane
Middletown, NY
1 bd1 ba735
Single Family
$585K
2078 Route 6
Middletown, NY
3 bd3 ba1,332
Single Family
$480K
36 Hoover Drive
Middletown, NY
4 bd3 ba2,331
Single Family
$370K
145 Wawayanda Avenue
Middletown, NY
3 bd2 ba1,248
Condo
$520K
29 Avoncroft Lane
Middletown, NY
3 bd3 ba2,567
Single Family
$393K
1 Chestnut Street
Middletown, NY
3 bd1 ba1,100
Single Family
$430K
17 Janice Drive
Middletown, NY
3 bd2 ba1,784
Mobile Home
$70K
301 3rd Avenue
Middletown, NY
2 bd2 ba800
Residential Multi Family
$1.4M
1 Royal Acres Drive
Middletown, NY
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$319K
37 California Avenue
Middletown, NY
3 bd1 ba1,152
Single Family
$299K
21 Dolson Avenue
Middletown, NY
2 bd1 ba1,181
Condo
$340K
5 Kendal Lane
Middletown, NY
2 bd3 ba1,241
Single Family
$278K
22 Chestnut Street
Middletown, NY
4 bd2 ba1,548
Single Family
$349K
39 Cedar Court
Middletown, NY
3 bd2 ba1,540
Condo
$300K
2 S Aspen Road
Middletown, NY
3 bd2 ba1,884
Single Family
$449K
60 Peach Place
Middletown, NY
3 bd4 ba2,041
Single Family
$525K
29 Beth Drive
Middletown, NY
4 bd2 ba1,716
Single Family
$649K
39 Goffredo Court
Middletown, NY
3 bd3 ba2,736
Single Family
$520K
81 Silver Lake Sctn Road
Middletown, NY
3 bd3 ba1,660
Residential Multi Family
$575K
20 John Street
Middletown, NY
3 bd3 ba
Single Family
$575K
180 Mt Orange Road
Middletown, NY
5 bd2 ba2,432
Single Family
$525K
225 Upper Road
Middletown, NY
3 bd2 ba2,065
Single Family
$625K
45 Randall Heights
Middletown, NY
3 bd3 ba2,053
Single Family
$400K
568 County Route 49
Middletown, NY
3 bd3 ba1,593
Single Family
$1.6M
430 Kirbytown Road
Middletown, NY
4 bd3 ba2,774
Residential Multi Family
$400K
25 Mill Street
Middletown, NY
4 bd2 ba
Single Family
$515K
86 Maples Road
Middletown, NY
4 bd3 ba2,484
Residential Multi Family
$600K
215 Linden Avenue
Middletown, NY
6 bd2 ba
Single Family
$399K
4 Saint Eve Court
Middletown, NY
3 bd2 ba1,446
Single Family
$400K
341 Highland Ave Extension
Middletown, NY
5 bd2 ba1,664
Single Family
$160K
32 Hidden Valley Drive
Middletown, NY
2 bd2 ba1,296
Residential Multi Family
$630K
317 E Main Street
Middletown, NY
10 bd4 ba
Single Family
$700K
9 School House Road
Middletown, NY
4 bd3 ba2,192
Residential Multi Family
$460K
8 Roberts Street
Middletown, NY
5 bd2 ba
Single Family
$400K
12 Todd Drive
Middletown, NY
3 bd2 ba1,799
Single Family
$1.2M
2 White Horse Road
Middletown, NY
3 bd3 ba4,225
Single Family
$569K
29 Murray Road
Middletown, NY
5 bd3 ba2,202
Single Family
$465K
122 Rolling Meadows Road
Middletown, NY
3 bd2 ba2,055
Condo
$425K
83 Deer Ct Drive
Middletown, NY
3 bd3 ba1,919
Condo
$290K
66 Deer Ct Drive
Middletown, NY
2 bd2 ba1,146
Condo
$295K
2 Durham Court
Middletown, NY
2 bd3 ba1,241
Single Family
$475K
153 Ridgewood Avenue
Middletown, NY
3 bd2 ba1,577
Condo
$199K
326 Concord Lane
Middletown, NY
2 bd2 ba924
Single Family
$475K
12 Weather Vane Way
Middletown, NY
3 bd3 ba2,055
Single Family
$380K
6 Charlotte Mews
Middletown, NY
3 bd2 ba1,413
Condo
$470K
22 Atwood Drive
Middletown, NY
3 bd3 ba1,723
Single Family
$39K
406 4th Avenue
Middletown, NY
2 bd1 ba910
Showing 1–50 of 59 · Page 1 of 2
About Middletown Real Estate
Middletown, New York offers a diverse real estate market with 59 homes currently for sale. Whether you're looking for a starter home, family property, or luxury estate, Middletown has options for every budget and lifestyle.
Average listing price: $697,113 · 59 homes available
Frequently Asked Questions
The average home price in Middletown is $697,113. Prices range from $39,000 to $3,000,000 depending on location and features.
There are currently 59 homes for sale in Middletown, New York. This inventory includes various property types from single-family homes to condos and townhouses.
Homes in Middletown typically stay on the market for 79 days. Market conditions can vary by neighborhood and price point, so working with a local agent can help you understand current trends.
Before buying in Middletown, research different neighborhoods, understand your budget relative to the $697,113 average, and consider factors like commute times, schools, and local amenities that matter to you.