New York

Homes for Sale in Middletown

“59 active listings in Middletown, New York · Median list price $575,000”

59 listings

Avg $697,113

79 days avg

Search All 59 Homes

Explore

Market Overview

Middletown Real Estate at a Glance

Current market statistics for Middletown, NY

Active Listings

$697K

Avg Price

$575K

Median Price

$326

Price/Sqft

2,139

Avg Sqft

Avg Days

Price Range

From

$39,000

$3,000,000

Property Types

Single Family

Avg $520K

Residential Multi Family

Avg $1.1M

Commercial

Avg $1.3M

Condo

Avg $328K

Nearby Cities

Explore homes for sale in cities near Middletown, New York

Milford, Pennsylvania

Bushkill, Pennsylvania

109 homes for sale

39 mi away

Greentown, Pennsylvania

East Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

154 homes for sale

47 mi away

Lake Ariel, Pennsylvania

111 homes for sale

48 mi away

Ridgefield, Connecticut

21 homes for sale

49 mi away

Listing selection

Homes to Explore

Active listings from the middletown collection

$675K

225 Brown Road

Middletown, NY

$575K

180 Mt Orange Road

Middletown, NY

$450K

3 Arden Court

Middletown, NY

$300K

2 S Aspen Road

$839K

225 Van Duzer Road

More listings

Homes for Sale in Middletown

Every active listing in Middletown, browsable page by page.

Single Family

$465K

168 Shawangunk Road

Middletown, NY

3 bd2 ba1,912

Single Family

$333K

23 Harrison Street

Middletown, NY

3 bd1 ba1,152

Multi-Family

$450K

41 Houston Avenue

Middletown, NY

4 bd2 ba

Single Family

$450K

30 Murray Road

Middletown, NY

3 bd1 ba1,136

Single Family

$540K

31 Denman Road

Middletown, NY

4 bd3 ba2,176

Single Family

$300K

158 Cottage Street

Middletown, NY

3 bd2 ba1,610

Single Family

$339K

11 5th Street

Middletown, NY

2 bd2 ba960

Single Family

$370K

15 Old Anvil Lane

Middletown, NY

3 bd3 ba1,692

Single Family

$740K

210 Howells Turnpike

Middletown, NY

3 bd3 ba2,654

Single Family

$525K

245 Stony Ford Road

Middletown, NY

4 bd2 ba2,100

Condo

$245K

49 Jimal Drive

Middletown, NY

2 bd2 ba1,133

Single Family

$239K

26 Willow Place

Middletown, NY

3 bd2 ba1,316

Single Family

$539K

18 Hickory Place

Middletown, NY

3 bd3 ba2,225

Single Family

$610K

320 White Bridge Road

Middletown, NY

4 bd3 ba2,561

Single Family

$450K

153 Ridgewood Avenue

Middletown, NY

3 bd2 ba1,577

Condo

$625K

8 Green Court

Middletown, NY

3 bd3 ba2,548

Single Family

$360K

7 Rowan Street

Middletown, NY

2 bd2 ba1,322

Single Family

$339K

17 State Street

Middletown, NY

2 bd1 ba894

Single Family

$899K

255 Howells Road

Middletown, NY

5 bd5 ba4,200

Land

$135K

43 Clinton Street

Middletown, NY

0 bd0 ba

Single Family

$175K

488 Tally Ho Road

Middletown, NY

1 bd1 ba748

Single Family

$479K

3 Sharon Drive

Middletown, NY

3 bd2 ba1,592

Single Family

$175K

488 Tally Ho Road

Middletown, NY

1 bd1 ba748

Single Family

$389K

4 Harding Street

Middletown, NY

4 bd2 ba1,416

Single Family

$355K

122 Castle High Road

Middletown, NY

3 bd1 ba1,830

Single Family

$515K

23 Marcy Lane

Middletown, NY

4 bd2 ba1,732

Single Family

$330K

89 Prince Street

Middletown, NY

2 bd2 ba1,008

Single Family

$300K

32 W Conkling Avenue

Middletown, NY

2 bd1 ba1,010

Single Family

$549K

25 Georges Road

Middletown, NY

4 bd3 ba2,680

Single Family

$675K

140 Burnt Corners Road

Middletown, NY

3 bd4 ba2,800

Single Family

$499K

7 Scotchtown Drive

Middletown, NY

3 bd3 ba1,796

Single Family

$490K

11 Avoncroft Lane

Middletown, NY

3 bd4 ba2,521

Residential Multi Family

$550K

36 Wallkill Avenue

Middletown, NY

0 bd0 ba

Single Family

$210K

19 Bonnell Street

Middletown, NY

2 bd1 ba1,084

Condo

$337K

5 Kendal Lane

Middletown, NY

2 bd3 ba1,241

Single Family

$450K

28 Wilson Street

Middletown, NY

3 bd3 ba1,624

Single Family

$390K

44 Orchard Hill

Middletown, NY

3 bd1 ba1,080

Single Family

$325K

66 Patio Road

Middletown, NY

3 bd2 ba1,440

Single Family

$325K

68 Ridgewood Avenue

Middletown, NY

2 bd1 ba1,117

Single Family

$535K

19 Randall Terrace

Middletown, NY

4 bd4 ba2,088

Single Family

$590K

45 Randall Heights

Middletown, NY

3 bd3 ba2,053

Single Family

$500K

37 Meadow View Drive

Middletown, NY

3 bd3 ba1,781

Single Family

$895K

411 Mt Joy Road

Middletown, NY

4 bd3 ba3,296

Single Family

$375K

13 Brewster Drive

Middletown, NY

3 bd1 ba1,456

Condo

$349K

15 Kendal Lane

Middletown, NY

2 bd3 ba1,241

Land

$175K

385 Midland Lake Road

Middletown, NY

0 bd0 ba

Single Family

$629K

744 Mt Hope Road

Middletown, NY

4 bd3 ba2,600

Condo

$152K

394 Concord Lane

Middletown, NY

1 bd1 ba735

Single Family

$499K

12 Walnut Lane

Middletown, NY

4 bd2 ba1,932

Single Family

$395K

24 Mountain Avenue

Middletown, NY

4 bd2 ba1,428

Showing 1–50 of 59 · Page 1 of 2

Beyond the listings

Continue exploring Middletown

Turn the listings into a short list with a clearer read on the Middletown market, its neighborhoods, and the home features that matter to you.

Refine Middletown search All New York homes

Local market guide

Middletown Housing Market

Browse 59 active listings in Middletown, New York. The median list price for this active inventory is $575,000. Compare the price and property details reported in each listing.

Median list price $575,000 · Range $39,000–$3,000,000 · 59 active listings

Buyer questions

Frequently Asked Questions

How many active listings are available in Middletown, New York?

The current inventory contains 59 active listings in Middletown, NY.

What is the average list price in Middletown, New York?

The average list price among current active listings in Middletown, NY is $697,113. Current list prices range from $39,000 to $3,000,000.

What is the median list price in Middletown?

The median list price among current active listings in Middletown, NY is $575,000.

What is the average days on market for active listings in Middletown?

Current active listings in Middletown, NY report an average of 79 days on market.

What is the average list price per square foot in Middletown?

The average list price per square foot among current active listings in Middletown, NY is $326.

Shape your search

Browse Middletown by home feature

Homes with Solar Features Homes with EV Chargers Homes with Pools Waterfront Homes Homes with Views Homes with Recorded Price Reductions Listings Added to PropertySimple in the Past 7 Days Homes Built Since 2024

Nationwide collections

Explore by listing details

Waterfront ListingsListings Marked Waterfront Listings in Mountain StatesSix-State Collection Multi-Family & Commercial ListingsListings by Property Type Listings with 3+ BedroomsThree or More Bedrooms Listings Priced at $1.5M+Listings by Asking Price Listings Built Since 2015Listings by Year Built

Ready to make the list yours?

Use the full search to set your price, beds, property type, and must-have features for Middletown.

Search Middletown homes

Homes for Sale in Middletown

Middletown Real Estate at a Glance

Price Range

Property Types

Nearby Cities

Homes to Explore

More from Middletown

225 Brown Road

180 Mt Orange Road

3 Arden Court

2 S Aspen Road

225 Van Duzer Road

30 Daly Road

60 Peach Place

47 Brick Pond Road

Homes for Sale in Middletown

168 Shawangunk Road

23 Harrison Street

41 Houston Avenue

30 Murray Road

31 Denman Road

158 Cottage Street

11 5th Street

15 Old Anvil Lane

210 Howells Turnpike

245 Stony Ford Road

49 Jimal Drive

26 Willow Place

18 Hickory Place

320 White Bridge Road

153 Ridgewood Avenue

8 Green Court

7 Rowan Street

17 State Street

255 Howells Road

43 Clinton Street

488 Tally Ho Road

3 Sharon Drive

488 Tally Ho Road

4 Harding Street

122 Castle High Road

23 Marcy Lane

89 Prince Street

32 W Conkling Avenue

25 Georges Road

140 Burnt Corners Road

7 Scotchtown Drive

11 Avoncroft Lane

36 Wallkill Avenue

19 Bonnell Street

5 Kendal Lane

28 Wilson Street

44 Orchard Hill

66 Patio Road

68 Ridgewood Avenue

19 Randall Terrace

45 Randall Heights

37 Meadow View Drive

411 Mt Joy Road

13 Brewster Drive

15 Kendal Lane

385 Midland Lake Road

744 Mt Hope Road

394 Concord Lane

12 Walnut Lane

24 Mountain Avenue

Middletown Housing Market

Frequently Asked Questions

How many active listings are available in Middletown, New York?

What is the average list price in Middletown, New York?

What is the median list price in Middletown?

What is the average days on market for active listings in Middletown?

What is the average list price per square foot in Middletown?

Browse Middletown by home feature

Explore by listing details

Ready to make the list yours?