New York
Homes for Sale in Shelter Island
“Discover your next home in Shelter Island”
18 listings
Avg $3,649,111
189 days avg
Explore
Market Overview
Shelter Island Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Shelter Island, NY
18
Active Listings
$3.6M
Avg Price
$3.9M
Median Price
3,296
Avg Sqft
189
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$895,000
To
$6,995,000
Handpicked
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest shelter island homes homes
Featured
More Shelter Island Homes
Discover more properties that match this lifestyle
Single Family
$5.5M
11 Sunnyside Avenue
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd6 ba4,000
Single Family
$4.4M
100 S Ferry Road
Shelter Island, NY
6 bd8 ba5,622
Single Family
$3.9M
8 Hilo Drive
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd6 ba3,985
Single Family
$2.0M
23 Osprey Rd
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd4 ba3,484
Single Family
$6.5M
28 S Menantic Rd
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd6 ba3,863
Single Family
$4.3M
141A N Ferry Road
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd7 ba5,500
Single Family
$3.5M
9 Locust Woods Drive
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd4 ba3,856
Single Family
$2.4M
5 Marc Street
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd4 ba2,777
Browse
Homes for Sale in Shelter Island
Every active listing in Shelter Island, browsable page by page.
Single Family
$7.0M
33 Dinah Rock Road
Shelter Island, NY
6 bd4 ba
Single Family
$4.8M
90 Peconic Avenue
Shelter Island, NY
5 bd4 ba3,325
Single Family
$2.7M
3 Conrad Rd
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd4 ba2,000
Single Family
$5.4M
9 Margarets Drive
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd6 ba
Land
$895K
9 Hillside Drive
Shelter Island, NY
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$2.4M
5 Marc Street
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd4 ba2,777
Single Family
$5.5M
11 Sunnyside Avenue
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd6 ba4,000
Single Family
$6.5M
28 S Menantic Rd
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd6 ba3,863
Single Family
$4.8M
90 Peconic Ave
Shelter Island, NY
5 bd4 ba3,325
Single Family
$3.5M
9 Locust Woods Drive
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd4 ba3,856
Single Family
$2.0M
23 Osprey Rd
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd4 ba3,484
Single Family
$3.9M
8 Hilo Drive
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd6 ba3,985
Single Family
$4.3M
141A N Ferry Road
Shelter Island, NY
4 bd7 ba5,500
Single Family
$1.4M
20 Crescent Way
Shelter Island, NY
3 bd2 ba1,575
Land
$995K
12 Hilo Dr
Shelter Island, NY
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$4.4M
100 S Ferry Road
Shelter Island, NY
6 bd8 ba5,622
Single Family
$4M
100 Peconic Avenue
Shelter Island, NY
3 bd3 ba1,626
Single Family
$1.4M
4 Duvall Place
Shelter Island, NY
3 bd2 ba1,200
Showing 1–18 of 18 · Page 1 of 1
About Shelter Island Real Estate
Shelter Island, New York offers a diverse real estate market with 18 homes currently for sale. Whether you're looking for a starter home, family property, or luxury estate, Shelter Island has options for every budget and lifestyle.
Average listing price: $3,649,111 · 18 homes available