# 37 John Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

> **TL;DR:** 3bd/5ba single family, $8,500,000 ($3400/sqft), built 1882, 2,500 sqft.
> Fireplace, Hardwood. Est. $45,460/mo. Listed 23 days.

## Property at a Glance

| Attribute | Value |
|-----------|-------|
| Price | $8,500,000 |
| Price/sqft | $3400 |
| Bedrooms | 3 |
| Bathrooms | 4 full, 1 half |
| Square Feet | 2,500 |
| Year Built | 1882 |
| Lot Size | 20,038 sqft (0.46 acres) |
| Stories | 2 |
| Property Type | Single Family (Other) |
| Status | For Sale |
| Days on Market | 23 |

## Why This Home Stands Out

- **Hardwood Floors** - Throughout the home

## Estimated Monthly Costs

| Category | Amount |
|----------|--------|
| Principal & Interest (20% down, 30-year at 6.5%) | $42,981 |
| Estimated Insurance | $2,479 |
| **Total** | **$45,460** |

## Key Amenities

- Fireplace
- Hardwood

## Property Highlights

- Built in 1882
- 0.46 acre lot
- 2 stories
- Fireplace

## Description

### Agent Description
A rare opportunity to own a beautifully renovated 1882 Gothic Victorian with approved permits to expand the main residence by approximately 1,500 square feet while adding a separate studio and pool house. Set on a meticulously landscaped 0.46-acre property in one of Sag Harbor Village's most charming and peaceful locations, the approved plans increase the main residence from approximately 2,500 to 4,000 square feet, expanding it from 3 bedrooms and 41/2 baths to 5-6 bedrooms and 7 baths. The plans also include a 585-square-foot studio structure and a 200-square-foot pool house, creating one of the Village's rare private compounds. Surrounded by historic turn-of-the-century homes, this architectural gem showcases timeless period details, including deep eaves, multiple gables, a dramatic turret, oversized Victorian windows, and soaring ceilings throughout, filling the home with exceptional natural light. The existing residence offers approximately 2,500 square feet of beautifully renovated living space with 3 bedrooms, 4 full baths, and 1 half bath. Every detail has been thoughtfully updated while preserving the home's historic character and architectural integrity. Additional highlights include a detached garage and a spectacular 45' x 12' heated gunite pool with an automatic cover, creating a private retreat in the heart of the Village. Whether enjoyed exactly as it stands today or transformed into an extraordinary estate, this offering combines the charm of a meticulously restored historic home with the rare opportunity to create an approximately 4,000-square-foot residence complemented by a detached studio, pool house, and resort-style outdoor amenities-a combination seldom available in Sag Harbor Village.

## Location

- **Address:** 37 John Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
- **County:** Suffolk
- **Coordinates:** 40.992224, -72.302422
- **Google Maps:** https://www.google.com/maps?q=40.992224,-72.302422

## Listing Agent

- **Name:** Lori Macgarva
- **Brokerage:** William Raveis (East Hampton)
- **Phone:** 631-324-8080

## Primary Photo

![37 John Street - Primary Photo](http://lh.rdcpix.com/6fc7d071afb486500e376894eabf1208l-f958086520r.jpg)

*33 total photos available on [listing page](https://www.propertysimple.ai/listing/37-john-street-sag-harbor-ny-11963-11852450)*

---

**MLS#:** 11852450 | **Updated:** 2026-08-01
**Source:** listhub

*Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.*

[View on PropertySimple](https://www.propertysimple.ai/listing/37-john-street-sag-harbor-ny-11963-11852450)

---

## Structured Data

```json
{
  "@context": "https://schema.org",
  "@type": "RealEstateListing",
  "name": "37 John Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963",
  "description": "A rare opportunity to own a beautifully renovated 1882 Gothic Victorian with approved permits to expand the main residence by approximately 1,500 square feet while adding a separate studio and pool house. Set on a meticulously landscaped 0.46-acre property in one of Sag Harbor Village's most charming and peaceful locations, the approved plans increase the main residence from approximately 2,500 to 4,000 square feet, expanding it from 3 bedrooms and 41/2 baths to 5-6 bedrooms and 7 baths. The pla",
  "url": "https://www.propertysimple.ai/listing/37-john-street-sag-harbor-ny-11963-11852450",
  "image": "http://lh.rdcpix.com/6fc7d071afb486500e376894eabf1208l-f958086520r.jpg",
  "datePosted": "2026-07-09",
  "price": 8500000,
  "priceCurrency": "USD",
  "address": {
    "@type": "PostalAddress",
    "streetAddress": "37 John Street",
    "addressLocality": "Sag Harbor",
    "addressRegion": "NY",
    "postalCode": "11963",
    "addressCountry": "US"
  },
  "geo": {
    "@type": "GeoCoordinates",
    "latitude": 40.992224,
    "longitude": -72.302422
  },
  "numberOfBedrooms": 3,
  "numberOfBathroomsTotal": 5,
  "numberOfFullBathrooms": 4,
  "numberOfPartialBathrooms": 1,
  "floorSize": {
    "@type": "QuantitativeValue",
    "value": 2500,
    "unitCode": "FTK"
  },
  "yearBuilt": 1882
}
```