Skip to main content
Front exterior at 425 Lighthouse Way, Sanibel, FL
Interior view at 425 Lighthouse Way, Sanibel, FL
Photo 51 at 425 Lighthouse Way, Sanibel, FL
For SaleActiveNew

425 Lighthouse Way, Sanibel, FL 33957

4beds
3baths
3,188sqft
1977

$3,250,000

$1,019/sqft · Est. $17,432/mo

About This Home

This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom single family at 425 Lighthouse Way in Sanibel, FL is listed for $3,250,000 ($1,019 per sqft). Built in 1977, the home offers 3,188 sqft of living space on a 0.54 acres lot.

Key Features

  • Built in 1977
  • 0.54 acre lot
  • Private pool
  • Fireplace
  • Waterfront

Property Details

1 story
3 full
2-car garage
1977

Amenities

PoolFireplaceWaterfrontSpaA/C
Listing Description

Welcome to 425 Lighthouse Way, tucked away on Sanibel's east end near the island's historic lighthouse. Palms sway over a paver drive as you arrive at this retreat, where more than 3,100 square feet of living space is built around water, light, and easy island days.

This four-bedroom home has three bedrooms and a den in the main house, plus a separate mother-in-law casita that opens to the lanai with its own bath and closet, giving family or guests their own private corner of paradise. Inside, the great room has tongue-and-groove tray ceilings with soft cove lighting, a fireplace, and a wall of wood-framed glass doors that bring the pool and canal right into the room.

The open kitchen is set up for gathering, with quartz counters, warm custom wood cabinetry, stainless appliances, wall oven, a wine cooler, and a pantry. Dinner can move from the dining room straight out to the lanai. The primary suite has warm wood floors, built-in shelving, and doors that open to the pool.

Its spa-like bath includes dual sinks and a walk-in shower with two shower heads. The guest rooms are bright and cheerful, and there is a bath with direct access to the pool. The den has a built-in double desk and floating shelves, so it works well as a home office, a hobby room, or overflow space when the whole crew comes to visit.

Outside is where island life takes over. A large screened lanai holds a sparkling pool, a raised spa, and a full outdoor kitchen. Past the screen, the canal is calm and emerald green, with a dock, a boat lift, and a kayak launch for easy paddles through the mangroves.

Boaters get direct access with no bridges, so the open water is only minutes from your backyard. The western exposure brings golden sunsets every evening. Concrete block construction, impact windows and doors, a 2023 tile roof, a tankless water heater, two A/C systems, and a two-car garage with an epoxy floor and Tesla charger all add peace of mind. The home is just a short ride from the beaches, shelling, and bike paths that make Sanibel special.

Monthly Cost Estimate

$17,432/mo

20% down · 6.5% · 30 years

Principal$2,350
Interest$14,083
Insurance$948
HOA$50

Estimates only. Actual payments may vary.

Location

425 Lighthouse Way

Sanibel, FL 33957

SANIBEL ESTATES

Features & Amenities

Interior Features

BreakfastBarBuiltInFeaturesTrayCeilingsDualSinksEntranceFoyerFrenchDoorsAtriumDoorsFireplaceKitchenIslandLivingDiningRoomPantryShowerOnlySeparateShowerCableTvWalkInClosetsWindowTreatmentsSplitBedrooms

Exterior Features

SecurityHighImpactDoorsIrrigationSprinklersOutdoorGrillOutdoorKitchenPatio

Property Details

Flooring

TileWood

Construction

Block Concrete Stucco

Pool Features

Pool

Outdoor Features

PatioPorch

Parking

OpenDrivewayGarage

Heating

Electric (Heating)CentralZoned

Cooling

Central AirCeiling Fan(s)ElectricZoned

Appliances

BuiltInOvenDryerDishwasherGasCooktopDisposalIceMakerMicrowaveRefrigeratorRefrigeratorWithIceMakerWineCoolerWasher

Questions & Answers

This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom single family at 425 Lighthouse Way is listed at $3,250,000 ($1,019/sqft). The estimated monthly payment is $17,432 based on 20% down, a 30-year loan at 6.5% interest, estimated insurance, HOA fees.

HOA fees are $50/month.

Key features include: Built in 1977, 0.54 acre lot, Private pool, Fireplace, Waterfront. Interior Features: BreakfastBar, BuiltInFeatures, TrayCeilings. Exterior Features: SecurityHighImpactDoors, IrrigationSprinklers, OutdoorGrill.

This property is listed by Eric Pfeifer.

EP

Eric Pfeifer

License 280522587

Agent at Pfeifer Realty Group

Listed by Pfeifer Realty Group · Broker phone: (239) 472-0004 · View on Broker Site · Broker website

MLS# 2026047447· Source: Florida Gulf Coast Multiple Listing Service, Inc.· 6 days on PropertySimple

Copyright © 2026 Florida Gulf Coast Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

425 Lighthouse Way, Sanibel, FL 33957

Open this listing in: