New York
Homes for Sale in Sag Harbor
“Discover 51 homes in Sag Harbor, New York”
51 listings
Avg $5,875,725
161 days avg
Explore
Market Overview
Sag Harbor Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Sag Harbor, NY
51
Active Listings
$5.9M
Avg Price
$4.5M
Median Price
$1273
Price/Sqft
4,615
Avg Sqft
161
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$1,250,000
To
$34,995,000
Nearby Cities
Explore homes for sale in cities near Sag Harbor, New York
East Hampton, NY
99 homes for sale
6 mi away
Southampton, NY
70 homes for sale
8 mi away
Hampton Bays, NY
64 homes for sale
14 mi away
Essex, Connecticut
16 homes for sale
25 mi away
Guilford, Connecticut
10 homes for sale
28 mi away
Branford, Connecticut
8 homes for sale
33 mi away
Westerly, Rhode Island
8 homes for sale
36 mi away
New Haven, Connecticut
23 homes for sale
38 mi away
Handpicked
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest sag harbor homes homes
Featured
More Sag Harbor Homes
Discover more properties that match this lifestyle
Single Family
$17.9M
2 B W Water Street
Sag Harbor, NY
8 bd10 ba11,726
Single Family
$5.8M
9 Shadyrest Drive
Sag Harbor, NY
8 bd8 ba6,400
Single Family
$4.5M
2587 Deerfield Road
Sag Harbor, NY
5 bd7 ba5,000
Single Family
$3.5M
2 A W Water Street
Sag Harbor, NY
8 bd10 ba12,400
Single Family
$17.9M
2 "B" W Water Street
Sag Harbor, NY
8 bd10 ba11,723
Single Family
$5.0M
12 Lincoln Street
Sag Harbor, NY
6 bd7 ba5,700
Single Family
$4.5M
9 Lincoln Street
Sag Harbor, NY
7 bd7 ba4,974
Single Family
$3.9M
1215 MIDDLE LINE HWY
Sag Harbor, NY
5 bd5 ba5,000
Browse
Homes for Sale in Sag Harbor
Every active listing in Sag Harbor, browsable page by page.
Condo
$2.3M
15 Church Street
Sag Harbor, NY
1 bd2 ba
Single Family
$2.4M
25 Meadow Street
Sag Harbor, NY
4 bd1 ba1,088
Single Family
$2.4M
58 Cliff Drive
Sag Harbor, NY
4 bd2 ba2,176
Single Family
$19.9M
59 MASHOMUCK DR
Sag Harbor, NY
6 bd8 ba
Single Family
$2.9M
1618 SAGG RD
Sag Harbor, NY
3 bd2 ba1,375
Single Family
$13.8M
3 & 11 Madison Street
Sag Harbor, NY
9 bd6 ba7,775
Single Family
$5.0M
83 Hampton Road
Sag Harbor, NY
3 bd3 ba2,400
Single Family
$1.3M
22 Chestnut Street
Sag Harbor, NY
3 bd1 ba1,068
Land
$1.7M
2236 DEERFIELD RD
Sag Harbor, NY
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$3.0M
100 Crescent Street
Sag Harbor, NY
3 bd2 ba1,600
Single Family
$3.4M
338 Main Street
Sag Harbor, NY
4 bd2 ba3,000
Single Family
$2.8M
31 NOYAC HARBOR RD
Sag Harbor, NY
3 bd2 ba1,800
Single Family
$1.6M
246 Hampton Street
Sag Harbor, NY
3 bd3 ba2,000
Single Family
$1.6M
22 OAK LN
Sag Harbor, NY
3 bd2 ba1,694
Single Family
$3.9M
1 Carver Street
Sag Harbor, NY
3 bd3 ba3,000
Single Family
$1.6M
11 Columbia Street
Sag Harbor, NY
4 bd2 ba1,660
Single Family
$5.2M
35 Sunset Drive
Sag Harbor, NY
5 bd7 ba
Single Family
$4.3M
27 South Valley Drive
Sag Harbor, NY
6 bd6 ba
Single Family
$2.9M
44 Robeson Boulevard
Sag Harbor, NY
4 bd4 ba2,000
Single Family
$5.3M
602 Ruggs Path
Sag Harbor, NY
5 bd7 ba
Single Family
$3.5M
6 Joseph Francis Blvd
Sag Harbor, NY
5 bd7 ba
Single Family
$6.0M
5 Rogers Court
Sag Harbor, NY
7 bd8 ba6,500
Single Family
$4.0M
278 Hampton Street
Sag Harbor, NY
6 bd7 ba4,500
Single Family
$6.0M
31 Carver Street
Sag Harbor, NY
4 bd5 ba3,000
Single Family
$7.2M
10 Bluff Point Lane
Sag Harbor, NY
4 bd3 ba2,800
Single Family
$2.8M
90 Denise Street
Sag Harbor, NY
3 bd4 ba2,500
Single Family
$6.5M
142 Six Pole Highway
Sag Harbor, NY
7 bd8 ba6,000
Single Family
$2.1M
22 Peninsula Drive
Sag Harbor, NY
4 bd4 ba3,174
Single Family
$5.7M
2136 Deerfield Road
Sag Harbor, NY
7 bd9 ba
Single Family
$3.6M
3 Wilson Pl
Sag Harbor, NY
5 bd4 ba3,100
Single Family
$3.9M
1215 MIDDLE LINE HWY
Sag Harbor, NY
5 bd5 ba5,000
Single Family
$2.3M
16 Redwood Road
Sag Harbor, NY
3 bd3 ba1,500
Single Family
$2.6M
47 Pine Neck Avenue
Sag Harbor, NY
3 bd4 ba2,400
Single Family
$5.0M
11 Sunset Beach Road
Sag Harbor, NY
4 bd4 ba2,700
Single Family
$13.0M
27 Ezekills Hollow
Sag Harbor, NY
5 bd7 ba4,868
Single Family
$4.3M
28 Lighthouse Lane
Sag Harbor, NY
6 bd6 ba3,943
Single Family
$2.0M
12 Rose Street
Sag Harbor, NY
4 bd3 ba1,755
Single Family
$7.2M
9 Suffolk Street
Sag Harbor, NY
5 bd4 ba3,400
Single Family
$4.4M
397 BRICK KILN RD
Sag Harbor, NY
4 bd4 ba5,000
Single Family
$17.9M
2 B W Water Street
Sag Harbor, NY
8 bd10 ba11,726
Single Family
$35.0M
2 A W Water Street
Sag Harbor, NY
8 bd10 ba12,400
Single Family
$17.9M
2 "B" W Water Street
Sag Harbor, NY
8 bd10 ba11,723
Single Family
$35.0M
2 "A" W Water Street
Sag Harbor, NY
8 bd10 ba16,974
Single Family
$5.0M
12 Lincoln Street
Sag Harbor, NY
6 bd7 ba5,700
Single Family
$4.3M
9 Lincoln Street
Sag Harbor, NY
7 bd7 ba4,974
Single Family
$6.5M
210 Redwood Road
Sag Harbor, NY
3 bd2 ba1,700
Land
$3.8M
46 Robertson Drive
Sag Harbor, NY
0 bd0 ba
Land
$1.9M
12 Ridge Drive
Sag Harbor, NY
0 bd0 ba
Commercial
$2.0M
12 Rose Street
Sag Harbor, NY
4 bd3 ba1,755
Single Family
$4.0M
60 Harbor Drive
Sag Harbor, NY
3 bd3 ba2,738
Showing 1–50 of 51 · Page 1 of 2
About Sag Harbor Real Estate
Sag Harbor is a coastal village on the east end of Long Island known for its historic homes and quiet residential streets. Many buyers arrive from New York City or other parts of the Northeast looking for a slower pace and proximity to the water. Character varies by neighborhood, with tree-lined streets near the harbor and more open settings farther inland. Lifestyle revolves around the harbor, beaches, and a compact downtown with restaurants, shops, and cultural venues. Parks and outdoor trails provide opportunities for walking, boating, and seasonal recreation. The area is served by the local public school district and nearby private options. Four distinct seasons shape daily life, with warm summers and cold winters. With 51 active listings and a median price of $4,450,000, the current market reflects a range of homes from $1,250,000 to $34,995,000 and an average size of 4,615 square feet.
Average listing price: $5,875,725 · 51 homes available
Frequently Asked Questions
The average price of homes in Sag Harbor is $5,875,725, with prices ranging from $1,250,000 to $34,995,000. The median price sits at $4,450,000, reflecting a mix of sizes and conditions. Homes typically average 4,615 square feet.
On average, homes stay on the market for 161 days in Sag Harbor. This timeframe allows buyers sufficient opportunity to view properties and consider options. The current inventory of 51 active listings contributes to this pace.
Sag Harbor is served by the local public school district and nearby private options. Families often evaluate both systems based on location and program offerings. Buyers relocating with children should visit schools directly to assess fit.
Sag Harbor has four distinct seasons, with warm summers and cold winters. Spring and fall provide moderate temperatures suitable for outdoor activities. This pattern aligns with typical Northeast coastal weather.
Daily life in Sag Harbor centers on the harbor, beaches, and a compact downtown with restaurants and shops. Parks and trails support walking, boating, and seasonal recreation. Buyers often cite proximity to the water as a main reason for moving here.