New York

Waterfront Homes for Sale in Sag Harbor

“Discover Sag Harbor Waterfront Living”

18 listings

Avg $11,464,167

Search All 18 Homes

Explore

Handpicked

Editor's Picks

Our curated selection of the finest waterfront homes homes

$35.0M

2 "A" W Water Street

Sag Harbor, NY

$35.0M

2 A W Water Street

Sag Harbor, NY

$20.8M

51 Mashomuck Drive

Sag Harbor, NY

$19.9M

59 MASHOMUCK DR

$17.9M

2 "B" W Water Street

Featured

More Waterfront Homes

Discover more properties that match this lifestyle

$35.0M

2 "A" W Water Street

Sag Harbor, NY

8 bd10 ba16,974

$35.0M

2 A W Water Street

Sag Harbor, NY

8 bd10 ba12,400

$20.8M

51 Mashomuck Drive

Sag Harbor, NY

7 bd10 ba7,800

$19.9M

59 MASHOMUCK DR

Sag Harbor, NY

6 bd8 ba

$17.9M

2 "B" W Water Street

Sag Harbor, NY

8 bd10 ba11,723

$17.9M

2 B W Water Street

Sag Harbor, NY

8 bd10 ba11,726

$13.0M

27 Ezekills Hollow

Sag Harbor, NY

5 bd7 ba4,868

$7.2M

10 Bluff Point Lane

Sag Harbor, NY

4 bd3 ba2,800

About Waterfront Homes in Sag Harbor

Sag Harbor's waterfront real estate market currently features 18 active listings with an average price of $11,464,167, spanning from $1,750,000 to $34,995,000. These exclusive properties offer direct access to the pristine waters of Sag Harbor Bay and the Atlantic Ocean, providing residents with spectacular views and private dockage options. The village's historic charm combined with its proximity to both the Hamptons and New York City makes waterfront living here particularly desirable.

Average listing price: $11,464,167 · 18 homes available

Frequently Asked Questions

The North Haven peninsula and properties along Sag Harbor Cove command premium prices due to their protected deep-water dockage and sunset views. These areas typically feature larger lots with direct water access compared to village center properties.

Waterfront properties in Sag Harbor typically carry higher assessments due to their premium location and amenities. Buyers should budget for taxes ranging from $20,000 to over $100,000 annually depending on the property's assessed value and specific location.

Most Sag Harbor waterfront homes require flood insurance through the National Flood Insurance Program, with premiums varying based on elevation and flood zone designation. Properties built before current flood regulations may qualify for significant rate subsidies under the NFIP's legacy program.