
New York
New Listings This Week for Sale in Middle Island
“Fresh Listings, Prime Middle Island Opportunities”
6 listings
Avg $414,830
Explore
Handpicked
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest new listings this week homes
Featured
More New Homes
Discover more properties that match this lifestyle

$639K
6 Julia Circle
Middle Island, NY
3 bd3 ba2,600

$510K
5 Robert Lane
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,716

$510K
5 Robert Lane
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,716

$330K
219 Artist Lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,100

$250K
223 Artist Lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
1 bd1 ba836

$250K
231 artist lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
1 bd1 ba850
About New Listings This Week in Middle Island
Middle Island, NY currently features 6 new listings with prices ranging from $249,990 to $639,000 and an average price of $414,830. These homes are situated in the heart of Suffolk County, offering buyers diverse options in this desirable Long Island community. With inventory moving steadily, now is an ideal time to explore what’s available in Middle Island.
Average listing price: $414,830 · 6 homes available
Frequently Asked Questions
The six active listings in Middle Island range from cozy starter homes near $249,990 to larger properties priced up to $639,000, with an average price of $414,830.
With only six homes on the market, Middle Island offers limited inventory, making it important for buyers to act quickly when they find a property that fits their needs.
First-time buyers should compare the current price range of $249,990 to $639,000 and review the average price of $414,830 to set realistic budgets and financing goals.