New York
Homes for Sale in Middle Island
“Discover your next home in Middle Island”
36 listings
Avg $508,933
47 days avg
Explore
Market Overview
Middle Island Real Estate at a Glance
Current market statistics for Middle Island, NY
36
Active Listings
$509K
Avg Price
$514K
Median Price
1,608
Avg Sqft
47
Avg Days
Price Range
From
$169,000
To
$999,999
Handpicked
Editor's Picks
Our curated selection of the finest middle island homes homes
Featured
More Middle Island Homes
Discover more properties that match this lifestyle
Single Family
$900K
1 Lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
5 bd4 ba3,955
Single Family
$600K
15 Marisa Drive
Middle Island, NY
3 bd3 ba2,396
Single Family
$465K
728 Birchwood Park Drive
Middle Island, NY
3 bd3 ba1,870
Single Family
$275K
230 Lake Pointe Circle
Middle Island, NY
2 bd1 ba930
Single Family
$899K
3 Sander Court
Middle Island, NY
5 bd3 ba2,896
Single Family
$535K
10 Tracie Lane
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,716
Single Family
$510K
5 Robert Lane
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,716
Condo
$250K
231 artist lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
1 bd1 ba850
Browse
Homes for Sale in Middle Island
Every active listing in Middle Island, browsable page by page.
Condo
$650K
53 Madison Circle
Middle Island, NY
4 bd3 ba2,322
Single Family
$510K
5 Robert Lane
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,716
Condo
$510K
5 Robert Lane
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,716
Condo
$250K
223 Artist Lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
1 bd1 ba836
Condo
$450K
59 Eric Drive
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,334
Single Family
$450K
59 Eric Drive
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,334
Single Family
$275K
230 Lake Pointe Circle
Middle Island, NY
2 bd1 ba930
Condo
$330K
219 Artist Lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,100
Single Family
$205K
16 Bailey Court
Middle Island, NY
1 bd1 ba750
Condo
$250K
231 artist lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
1 bd1 ba850
Condo
$595K
5 Charley Lane
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,670
Single Family
$585K
17 Arnold Drive
Middle Island, NY
3 bd3 ba1,002
Single Family
$585K
17 Arnold Drive
Middle Island, NY
3 bd3 ba1,002
Single Family
$600K
11 Winterberry Drive
Middle Island, NY
3 bd2 ba1,424
Single Family
$475K
6 Amesworth Court
Middle Island, NY
3 bd2 ba1,332
Condo
$475K
6 Amesworth Court
Middle Island, NY
3 bd2 ba1,332
Single Family
$600K
62 W Bartlett Road
Middle Island, NY
4 bd3 ba1,872
Condo
$549K
8 Hannah Lane
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,716
Single Family
$899K
3 Sander Court
Middle Island, NY
5 bd3 ba2,896
Single Family
$648K
21 Pine Cone Street
Middle Island, NY
5 bd3 ba2,029
Single Family
$169K
28 Bailey Court
Middle Island, NY
1 bd1 ba700
Single Family
$198K
129 Bailey Court
Middle Island, NY
1 bd1 ba700
Single Family
$600K
15 Marisa Drive
Middle Island, NY
3 bd3 ba2,396
Single Family
$325K
291 Middle Country Road
Middle Island, NY
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$900K
1 Lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
5 bd4 ba3,955
Condo
$628K
14 Julia Circle
Middle Island, NY
4 bd3 ba2,322
Single Family
$639K
6 Julia Circle
Middle Island, NY
3 bd3 ba2,600
Single Family
$519K
10 Casey Lane
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,670
Single Family
$200K
86 Bailey Court
Middle Island, NY
1 bd1 ba775
Commercial
$675K
217 Middle Country Road
Middle Island, NY
0 bd0 ba
Single Family
$535K
10 Tracie Lane
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba1,716
Single Family
$465K
728 Birchwood Park Drive
Middle Island, NY
3 bd3 ba1,870
Condo
$250K
280 Artist Lake Drive
Middle Island, NY
1 bd1 ba836
Single Family
$1.0M
7 Sander Court
Middle Island, NY
3 bd4 ba2,500
Single Family
$1.0M
7 Sander Court
Middle Island, NY
3 bd4 ba2,500
Single Family
$329K
605 Lake Court
Middle Island, NY
2 bd2 ba967
Showing 1–36 of 36 · Page 1 of 1
About Middle Island Real Estate
Middle Island, New York offers a diverse real estate market with 36 homes currently for sale. Whether you're looking for a starter home, family property, or luxury estate, Middle Island has options for every budget and lifestyle.
Average listing price: $508,933 · 36 homes available